Germany’s Interior Ministry, led by Alexander Dobrindt of the CDU/CSU, is facing criticism from members of its coalition partner, the Social Democratic Party (SPD), following plans to introduce indefinite pre-removal detention for migrants awaiting deportation.

Controversial Proposal Sparks Political Divide

Speaking at a migration conference in Munich on October 4, Dobrindt announced his intention to establish detention centers where certain migrants—particularly those convicted of crimes or considered a threat to public safety—could be held indefinitely before deportation.

The proposal is part of a broader tougher migration policy package being promoted by the CDU/CSU in response to rising public concern over irregular migration.

Coalition Tensions Over Migration Policy

However, the plan has triggered strong criticism within the governing coalition, with several SPD lawmakers accusing the Interior Ministry of overstepping legal and human rights boundaries.
SPD officials have argued that indefinite detention may violate EU law and fundamental rights protections, warning that Germany must not undermine its humanitarian commitments while managing migration challenges.

The debate underscores growing policy tensions within Germany’s coalition government as it seeks to balance security measures with human rights obligations in its ongoing efforts to reform migration policy.